I asked an AI for video ideas, and they were actually good
I didn't expect this to work so well. • Includes text generated by OpenAI's GPT-3 at my request: openai.com • Art by Chris Quay: www.chrisquay.com/ • Got an idea for a video? www.tomscott.com/contact/
Filmed safely: www.tomscott.com/safe/
OpenAI had no control or sign-off on this video, although I agreed to abide by their ethical guidelines and social media policy.
Thanks to Eddie the corgi's owner for introducing me to the folks at OpenAI: eddie_corg
Articles referenced:
doi.org/10.18653/v1%2F2020.findings-emnlp.301
artificialintelligence-news.com/2020/10/28/medical-chatbot-openai-gpt3-patient-kill-themselves/
thenextweb.com/neural/2021/01/19/gpt-3-is-the-worlds-most-powerful-bigotry-generator-what-should-we-do-about-it/
New River in Bowes Park image by Nick Cooper on Wikimedia Commons: commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:New_River_Bowes_Park.jpg
Licensed under CC-by 3.0, creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/deed.en
I'm at tomscott.com
on Twitter at tomscott
on Facebook at tomscott
and on Instagram as tomscottgo
Tom Scott
8 napja
I should clarify that by "out of ideas", I mean that I've only got enough to last me until the end of March, or maybe the middle of April if lockdown eases. The way I work, that's close enough that I start to get worried.
Beanbot Productions
14 órája
@Doctor Mari-who Scom Tott
M8 N8
Napja
I see one really bad idea that bots could do even today that would bring someone a lot of money but also a lot of misery to people, so I wont even bring it out of my head, purely because if I see that trend happening, I'll feel like shite(and, I'm aware of parallel thinking and I know that someone has probably thought of it and has no moral quandary about it). I see an army of people like hamsters in a wheel running away but never getting there 24/7/365, that's as far i'll go into it..
8192
Napja
E
Dan Quayles ITS SPELT POTATOE!
Napja
@TheMiningTeam "The point of GPT-3 is that it creates whole new sentences based on what it has seen before." YES EXACTLY! You do understand it is working off what it has access to? ITS NOT CREATING ANYTHOMNG FROM SCRATCH! Its copying everything it creates from other sentences. Combining words and phrases from other sentences and phrases. Since it doesnt know how to do it! it makes silly suggestions and impossible ones. This is why ARTIFICAL intelligence fails, it requires (REAL) INTELLEGNCE to do the things they try to get ARTIFICAL intelligence to do! You just cant code that!
TheMiningTeam
Napja
@Dan Quayles ITS SPELT POTATOE! Not anymore. The point of GPT-3 is that it creates whole new sentences *based* on what it has seen before.
Boudreaux Broletariat
2 perccel
the "impossible but fictional" video titles sound like HP lovecraft short stories
cheep the peanut
20 perccel
well, of course we don't know anything about such cliff, because it refuses to be one. successfully.
Evan Barnes
Órája
That car went by at just the right point in the sigmoid curve
Coolkidvinny
Órája
I confused in my time but confusion is not a matter of time. Time is the contingency of YOU ARE ARRESTED ON 4 COUNTS OF PURDER. girst pt!!!
garthvater111
2 órája
This ai is probably the mastermind behind half as interesting
Lieselotte Aya
2 órája
"Nostalgia for a thing that never existed" is called conservatism
Benevolent
3 órája
If the AI ever suggested the title of this video... is...would that pass the Turing test, or is that a fluke?
TommyWashow
3 órája
hypnospace outlaw - nostalgia for something that never existed
Drackar
4 órája
Some few of those are things that might come. They might exist... Ten years from now.
Neaox
4 órája
Google tells me that 'wistful' might be the world you're looking for when you mention nostalgia.
Anodyne Melody
4 órája
All cliffs refuse to be cliffs, they are continuously eroded by the water cycle. We just don't notice their desperation for suicide because it occurs on a geological time scale, not a human one. So please, have some empathy for the cliffs of the world for at some point they'll all have jumped into the sea.
MrAndrewsAnimations
4 órája
6:45 there never was a failed russian utopia yet...
LJCyrus1
4 órája
Might "The Cliff that refuses to be a Cliff" simply be someone who's named Cliff trying to change their legal name?
Plumjet09
4 órája
Half of these sounds like SCPs
L'éclair
5 órája
you know what would've made this video great? if we found out that this video was suggested by an ai.
SlopedOtter
5 órája
The best part of current gen AI is that it is absolutely hilarious, even when it works
owenmp4
5 órája
and I thought creative takeover was a while down the line
Imagine Kudryavka
6 órája
"The cliff that refuses to be a cliff" had me laughing, and I just woke up. Someone needs to make that into a serious video.
Jordan
6 órája
There WAS a white square of ice in Antarctica
M
6 órája
I mean Scheel's green contained deadly amounts of arsnic and it was developed during the dye industry boom which was part of the Industrial rev so it had something there.
OneBigPlayLister
6 órája
"The White Cube at the End of the World" sounds like a rejected Exurb1a video
NoodleBomber
6 órája
Anyone know where I can rent Jeremy Clarkson's Lottery of Death?
smokey notifier
7 órája
DO THIS: HOW MANY HOLES DOES IT TAKE TO FILL THE ALBERT HALL?
RogueBeats
7 órája
Plot Twist: these videos are real in a parallel universe wich the AI connects to.
Catunyti.6 .4
7 órája
Jeremy Clarkson's Lottery of Death
Atomicwinter 31
7 órája
I love how you could make a channel entirely about castro and everything about him. Like the poisoned milkshake that failed cuz the pills cracked when frozen, or UBRE BLANCA
Evin Drews
7 órája
You should've had the AI write the script in this video
GalaxyGal040-15
8 órája
I really wanna learn about Jeremy Clarkson's lottery of death now
Christopher Birnbaum
9 órája
feelin existential dread from this for some reason
ghostboy1225
9 órája
Anemoia is the name for nostalgia for something you've never experienced. the concept has a connotation of being for people who are younger than an event feeling nostalgia for said event. looking at popular "old style" letsplays or YT videos/website archives from when youtube/the internet was in its infancy. i think retro shooters play on this feeling heavily perhaps without realising the exact term.
JJ FX
9 órája
Hold up... are you telling me it came up with the CIA plot to assassinate Castro with explosive sea shells but didn't even know it was true??
Svatopluk Čech
10 órája
I can't believe I wasn't subscribed... Well, I'm now I guess
kackers
10 órája
If Jeremy Clarkson's Lottery of Death isn't a real game show in the next few years I am going to mighty disappointed
Hri7566
10 órája
cheater
Aaron Long
10 órája
Do your viewers know that kirbys dream is a videogame? I thought I'd see at least one comment about it by now but...
Aaron Long
10 órája
Do your viewers know that kirbys dream is a videogame? I thought I'd see at least one comment about it by now but...
Totally Not A Cylon
11 órája
Did you honestly expect no one in *your* audience would recognise Helena Blavatsky as the picture of that Nondescript Russian Baroness.
Benjamin Bradshaw
11 órája
Also, this is why we need critical thinking and to look for sources.
Daniel Budney
11 órája
Adding a restriction that the stories be True ... that sounds a lot like the interplay between the different parts of the brain, where the frontal lobe filters impulses and exerts self-control. What GPT-3 has managed seems analogous to what our brains manage during Dreaming or creative efforts like stringing together Poetry. An artist will apply rules to filter and rearrange concepts, but those are based on a World Model that the "AI" simply doesn't have yet. It doesn't have a concept of how things work; it only spots relationships.
Benjamin Bradshaw
11 órája
Nostalgia for a thing that never existed: Resonance - Home
Dekko22
11 órája
are you boxing yourself in with "what works"
Eric Bennett
11 órája
GPT-3 access gang
Kris Dreemurr
11 órája
You could try to make something like "Tom Scott Fictional" where there would be the fictional sotries animated or recorded like in 5:54 . Just an idea.
Batch Coder
12 órája
haha britain colonize moon
Sky Bug
12 órája
wait Tom the word is just fantasy 😭
AngrySlime- osu!
12 órája
7:15 that car timing was perfect
Not Eskinor
12 órája
"I don't think there's a word in the English language for 'nostalgia for a thing that never existed'." I'm sure the Germans have one lying around somewhere.
James Burton
12 órája
Wow! That's crazy!
EK X
13 órája
T. Scott: I don't think English has a word for "nostalgia for things that have never existed" Finland/Germany: Hold my kyykkyviini
Glaive
13 órája
2:07 …also known as “At Least One Fight Scene From Every Tokusatsu Ever”
scarylion.roar
13 órája
"The British Road That is Also A Boat" a car ferry or pontoon bridge
Jesus Acuna
13 órája
7:08 This was the most perfectly planned audio I've heard in a while Too bad it wasn't
NodeX
13 órája
All of the ideas you say don't work, I am interested in. I had no idea about any of them.
Willow Rose
13 órája
'I don't think there is a word for nostalgia for something that doesn't exist' Vaporwave Aesthetics, anemoia, Liminal Images You're welcome.
Willow Rose
13 órája
Excuse me, I forgot weirdcore.
dqtl !
13 órája
2:43 I'd love to see this
The middle man
13 órája
This is 2 minute papers with doctor karoly-zolnai-fehér.
The middle man
13 órája
Sorry if the misspelling of the name triggers you :((
Roland Katsuragi
13 órája
Tell me more of this Russian utopia in Yorkshire
Chiszle
13 órája
This is perfect for HUeye LetsPlay Channels who need to push endless streams of videos and merch on young audiences who would be better off watching you, Tom.
Jacob Falk
13 órája
Do some DIY stuff!
Raleigh Koehle
14 órája
I suppose the closest thing to nostalgia for things that never were would be the mandela effect
Tom Scott
13 órája
THANKS FOR WATCHING. Reach out to me directly for your guidance...!!! ..Whats@pp +1. 3 2 1. 2 5 1. 8 3 1 1..
sinisterLMN
14 órája
“The British Road That Is Also A Boat” ...so a hydrofoil then? 🤔
Tom Scott
13 órája
THANKS FOR WATCHING. Reach out to me directly for your guidance...!!! ..Whats@pp +1. 3 2 1. 2 5 1. 8 3 1 1..
Sinom
14 órája
At the "the green death and the industrial revolution" thing I was thinking of the DW episode "the crimson horror"
?
14 órája
Plot twist: Those video titles weren't actually fiction...
Batrax
15 órája
"Nostalgia for a thing that never existed" is called _rilirin_ in the language of dwarves in a webseries called Worth The Candle, a rational LitRPG story. Worth checking out by the way, it won't appeal to everyone but for those with the right taste it's absolutely amazing.
Daffyd Barnaby
15 órája
I think "nostalgia for things that never existed" is called hauntology?
KnitterX
15 órája
What if it turns out all those stories are in fact real and nobody beside GPT-3 knows yet?
Jakob
16 órája
Anemoia, Hiraeth and Vaporwave are words for nostalgia of a time that never happened (Courtesy of comments)
rifa khattak
16 órája
Be amazing as evaa @Tom Scott
Ryan O'Rourke
17 órája
I wonder will there be ai tinder profiles and ppl will be catfished by some 1s and 0s
Steven Osborn
17 órája
The British Road that is also a boat: Isn't that the Isle of Wight Chain Ferry?
Noname _game
17 órája
5:25 in German there ist a word for this. ;-)
neilomac
18 órája
"A word for nostalgia for a thing that never existed" - Not-stalgia? Non-stalgia? Lostalgia?
Jim Smith
18 órája
Don't get me wrong but road that is also a boat sounds like a interesting video to me :)
Nippletwister 2000
19 órája
Lofthouse is asking you to drive safely, because of the invisible things there... Don't be stupid, sheeple
Mantas Zlioba
19 órája
I asked an AI for video ideas, and they were actually good continues to talk about the AI
Vishnu Nittoor
19 órája
I think you're looking for the word 'anemoia'- It means "nostalgia for a time you've never known". Close enough, I'd say.
John M. Wilson
19 órája
I'm guessing your animator want British, the flag isn't right
Ashley Strober
20 órája
Nostalgia for a thing that could have existed Is often Hauntology
Nani??!!!?? nice
20 órája
Plot twist: This entire script to this video was written by the AI
Kuchiki Beyakuya
20 órája
"the white cube at the end of the world" haha what nonsense *sweats in blender*
Some Dude
21 órája
i honestly wouldn't mind if Tom made a video about a bridge over a motorway or about a warehouse in the middle of nowhere.
Tad Wood
21 órája
Communist AI confirmed
Matthew Anderson
22 órája
Heres a word for that felling "Saudade"
Stepan Kastanayevsky
22 órája
The dream of a Russian utopia in East Yorkshire let’s go
Varun VC
Napja
*Next Video Idea:* _How to look 8, 18, 48 and 68 at the same time._
KnuckleHunkybuck
Napja
Where is the location you found of the beach where you can hear the sea? Or did you just edit the audio in afterward?
alegend4evr
Napja
*invest another 10k into AI research fields*
Cly Marin
Napja
Tom scott had other things to be worried about, now that we have a generated tom scott, and a video script generator
nutzeeer
Napja
i bet that AI will be free at the end of the year.
Juiceboi PRO
Napja
TOM FULP IS THE IMPOSTER
John Marshall
Napja
02:21 The British Road That Is Also A Boat is not nonsense - boat means "Byeway Open to All Traffic"
Maciej Załucki
Napja
Well, the words "there never was any Russian utopia" may hurt some people more than you might've though.
hen ko
Napja
"The Airport That Lands Planes On Water." Wendover Productions has entered the chat.
Carl Hartwell
Napja
At the end there, I thought you were going to say _...when that happens, my job will get a bit harder..._ After all, you'll have much more competition.
taped wall
Napja
I hate how this could be editors used to smear you name and credible it’s as a reporter and as long as the voice was loud and the ring anuff it would make people hate your and you followers anyways despight that it’s a great video I love your work
hen ko
Napja
an interesting topic nonetheless.
jimbobbyrnes
Napja
well there is always the option of starting a second channel for coding/mathematics teaching. i feel like if you did videos like Ben Eater about whatever sciences that interest you it would probably take off.
Raina Ramsay
Napja
"They would be wonderful to make, but I can't, because they're not true", says the guy who's already done a video about the AI virus that deleted a century, and the day Google stopped checking passwords
Yuuup
Napja
*ALTSTALGIA*
James Postlethwaite
Napja
What about the bird statues of cumbria that start at maryport roman museum they are mostly in perfect condition and left by romans